How Immigration Influences Job Growth Under Current U.S. Leadership

Layoff notice in a yellow box.

Scrutiny intensifies as the Biden-Harris administration faces criticism over job growth discrepancies and a shift favoring foreign-born workers.

At a Glance

  • Bureau of Labor Statistics report shows foreign-born workers gained over 1 million jobs, while native-born Americans lost nearly 800,000
  • Government overstated job gains by 818,000 between March 2023 and March 2024
  • Economists and former President Trump criticize current immigration and labor policies
  • Pew Research study reveals 20% increase in jobs held by immigrants over 15 years
  • Concerns grow over economic stability and labor competition for American citizens

Job Growth Overstatement Raises Concerns

The Biden-Harris administration is facing increased scrutiny as recent reports reveal significant discrepancies in job growth figures. The government has admitted to overstating job gains by 818,000 between March 2023 and March 2024, leading to questions about the accuracy of economic reports. This revelation comes as part of the largest job data revision by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) in 15 years, casting doubt on the administration’s economic narrative.

Economists and even Federal Reserve Chairman Jay Powell have expressed skepticism about the accuracy of job reports. Powell stated that the job numbers “may be a bit overstated,” highlighting the growing concern among experts.

Foreign-Born Workers Gain While Native-Born Americans Lose Jobs

A concerning trend has emerged from the latest Bureau of Labor Statistics report, indicating that foreign-born workers gained over 1 million jobs in the past year, while native-born Americans lost nearly 800,000 jobs. This shift in employment dynamics has raised alarms about the current administration’s labor market policies and their impact on American workers.

“The U.S. labor market is turning into a temp agency for foreign workers and gov’t bureaucrats,” Antoni wrote, pointing out that native-born Americans are still grappling with post-pandemic job shortages, with employment numbers down by 873,000 since 2020.

The disparity in job growth between foreign-born and native-born workers has become a focal point of criticism against the Biden-Harris administration’s economic and immigration policies. Former President Donald Trump has weighed in on the issue, stating, “So foreigners coming in illegally, largely illegally into our country, took the jobs of native-born Americans and I’ve been telling you that’s what’s going to happen.”

Long-Term Trends and Economic Implications

A Pew Research Center study has further highlighted the changing landscape of the American workforce. The study revealed a 20% increase in jobs held by legal immigrants and undocumented individuals over the last 15 years, compared to less than a 10% increase for native-born workers. This long-term trend underscores the growing role of immigrant labor in the U.S. economy and raises questions about future job prospects for American citizens.

The employment trends have intensified debates over economic and labor competition, as well as the future of native-born workers in the labor market. These findings call for a reassessment of current policies and a strategic approach to national employment and immigration issues. As the Biden-Harris administration continues to face criticism over its handling of the economy, the focus on job creation and fair employment opportunities for American citizens is likely to remain a central issue in political discourse.

Sources:

Sudden shift in jobs data shows workers are struggling to survive Biden-Harris inflation

Under Biden-Harris, Foreign Workers Gain Over 1 Million Jobs While Nearly 800K Americans Lose Jobs